How to deal with contradictions within Hinduism?



A layman may find contradictions within Hinduism.

Many a time, even among scholars, debates take place over which principle is correct and which is not.

Hinduism consists of principles for living a virtuous life.

Some of these principles could contradict one another due to many reasons.


Click below to watch the video - What India lacks? What needs to be done! - Prof. K Ramasubramanian 


What India lacks? What needs to be done! - Prof. K Ramasubramanian


Hinduism evolves as time progresses

Hinduism is very ancient.

The Puranas narrate incidents as old as 1.8 billion years or even as recent as a few thousand years.

A piece of advice may apply only to a particular period of time.

A billion years ago, what was relevant and valid may not be today.

Or it may have been suitably modified and we are unaware of it.


Principles for each yuga can be different

This is called yuga dharma.

It's possible that what applies during Tretayuga won't apply during Kaliyuga.

There is even a specific code of conduct that applies in Kaliyuga called Kalyapat dharma.

So, we may be cherry-picking principles and preaching them at the wrong time and in the wrong context, causing confusion.


There are different systems within Hinduism

Hinduism is not a monolithic religion.

It consists of umpteen distinct practices, some of them redundant and even extinct.

Shaiva principles can be different from the principles of Vaishnavas.

Rigvedic practices can differ from Yajurvedic practices.

Within one particular branch of Veda, there can be many different ways to perform rituals depending on which grihya sutra your family adheres to.


How to deal with contradictions?

Mixing systems and traditions can lead to confusion, so don't do it.

It is also important to be aware of the time and circumstances of a particular shastra or principle and check whether they are valid today.


Copyright © 2023 | Vedadhara | All Rights Reserved. | Designed & Developed by Claps and Whistles
| | | | |